weird c# error in clustering

Hello,

I am using SQL Server 2012 SE clustering on Hypervservers (virtual machines). SQL Server 2012 or prior Standard Editions supports 2 node clustering only. I noticed a strange issue on one node which upon failover is throwing a weird error for the applications which when failed back works fine.
The error on the webapplication page upon performing a failover is:
The client and server cannot communicate, because they do not possess a common algorithm.

To this node I am able to connect to SQL Server from SSMS and run tsql statements and also when I run profiler I am seeing connections from webservers as expected. Tried matching the TLS setting with the node where it never errors out but still no luck. This is happening only on this node. The other node which is currently active doesnt have any issues. 

Looked into sqlserver error log, cluster event log and noticed nothing unusual.

So we want to evict that node and create a new one and add it to the cluster. Before proceeding further I would like to know if anyone faced a similar issue?

Thanks